We obtained a new class of solutions for a relativistic anisotropic compact star by utilizing the Karmarkar embedding condition. To obtain the closed-form solution a suitable form of one of the gravitational potentials has been chosen to determine the other by analyzing the Karmarkar condition. The resulting solutions are found to be well-behaved and regular and could describe a compact stellar object. Considering the current estimated values of the mass and radius of the pulsar 4U1820 − 30 as input parameters, all the physically relevant parameters are shown to be well-behaved to a very good degree of accuracy.
Bikram Keshari Parida, Shreya Majumder, Shyam Das, Koushik Chakraborty, Farook Rahaman. Relativistic models of anisotropic superdense star in the regime of Karmarkar's condition[J]. Communications in Theoretical Physics, 2023, 75(2): 025403. DOI: 10.1088/1572-9494/acaaf5
1. Introduction
Scientists have been amazed by the relativistic compact objects over the last few decades. Towards the end of their lifetime, stars having an initial mass larger than Chandrasekhar's limit collapse to form compact objects. When gravity overpowers the pressure due to neutron degeneracy, the situation leads to the formation of neutron stars. On the other hand, in white dwarf stars, the effect of gravity is balanced by the pressure due to electron degeneracy. In the year 1916, for the first time, Schwarzschild [1] obtained the exact solution of static spherically symmetric compact objects in hydro-static equilibrium which has the vacuum exterior gravitational field. After that, many researchers continuously investigated the exact solution of compact stellar objects. The nature of the matter composition and distributions of the star decides its interior geometry and hence the structure as a whole. The interior geometry and nature of the compact stellar configuration can be known by assuming a particular suitable metric potential and solving the Einstein field equations. But finding a suitable metric potential that satisfies all the regularity condition is an extremely difficult job. For the modelling of the realistic compact stellar object, the search for the exact solution of the Einstein field equations has been an intense area of relativistic astrophysics.
Usually, for the study of compact stellar structure in the general relativity context, the isotropic nature of the matter distribution has been considered, i.e. people have considered the perfect fluid which has equal tangential (pt) and radial (pr) pressures. But in reality, the anisotropy in the interior of the stellar structure can arise because of many reasons. In a compact object, whenever the pressures in the radial and tangential directions are not the same they produce anisotropy. Since the paper by Bowers and Liang [2], in the context of general relativity, there has been ample research in the study of the role of anisotropy in a relativistic star. The geometry of spacetime inside the star matches the Schwarzschild geometry outside the star. The extremely dense matter inside the compact star is relativistic. When the density becomes of the order of 1015gm − cm−3, local anisotropy may arise inside the star [3]. Kippenhahn and Weigert [4] indicated that anisotropy can be introduced by the existence of a type 3A superfluid or by the presence of a solid stellar core. Anisotropy can also be possible because of the different kinds of phase transitions (Sokolov [5]) or pion condensation (Sawyer [6]). In the framework of a relativistic anisotropic fluid, Herrera and Santos [7] investigated the influences of slow rotation in stars, and Letelier [8] studied the mixture of two gases, such as ionized hydrogen and electrons. Weber [9] illustrated that strong magnetic fields act as a means for generating anisotropy in pressure inside a compact and spherical object. For a typical polytropic index, Thirukkanesh and Ragel [10] determined exact solutions to Einstein's field equations for a spherically symmetric distribution of anisotropic matter. Researchers [11–13] explored various aspects of polytropic EOS in the studies of a static perfect fluid sphere. Thirukkanesh and Ragel [14] have employed modified Van der Waals EOS to characterise charged fluid spheres having anisotropic pressure. Wormholes [15] and gravastars [16, 17] are also considered anisotropic. Recently, the effect of tidal deformation has also been studied by considering the anisotropic matter distributions [18–20]. Gedela et al [21] presented a core-envelope model of an anisotropic star. A three-layered model of a compact star was reported by [22]. Therefore, it is important to study the nature of the space-time of anisotropic fluid spheres under the general theory of relativity.
The necessary and sufficient condition to embed a 4-dimensional spherically symmetric space in a 5-dimensional space was proposed by Karamakar [23]. This condition can be expressed as a simple equation of the components of the Riemannian curvature tensor. Many researchers used this condition for general relativistic studies of compact stars [22, 24–28]. Some researchers [24, 25, 27, 29–32] modelled anisotropic stars using Karmakar's condition. Using this nice condition, the charged anisotropic star was modelled by [33–35]. Deb et al [36] proposed a new model of a compact star under f(T) gravity in which they utilized this condition to find out one of the metric potentials. Recently, Pant et al [26, 37] used the technique of gravitational decoupling in their model for the charged compact star. They have considered an embedding class I type spacetime. Inspired by some earlier research investigations, in this present paper, we explore static anisotropic fluid solutions of Einstein Field equations in the framework of Karmarkar's condition that could describe observationally compatible compact stellar objects. In particular, we explore the well-known pulsar 4U1820 − 30. To construct the model, we have assumed a specific type of metric potential grr. This particular form of the metric potential was obtained by Das et al [38] in developing a compact stellar model under a specific anisotropic profile. Then using the famous Karmakar's embedding class—I condition and the form of metric grr, we calculated the expression for gtt. All the physical parameters are well-behaved and regular inside the anisotropic star which implies a realistic description of astrophysical compact objects.
In the present paper, we use that metric to develop models of the dense compact star under the well-known Karmakar condition. More specifically, we are interested in whether this particular geometry can generate the static stellar model of compact objects and it is found that under the Karmakar condition, it is possible to obtain the stellar model. Another interesting point of this model is that under certain conditions between model parameters (α, β, R), the assumed metric potential reduces to the well-known Tolman metric. The assumed metric potential which reduces to the Tolman solution with suitable fixation of model parameters represents a compact stellar structure.
This paper is organised as follows. We discuss the Einstein field equations with pressure anisotropy for the compact object in section 2. In section 3, we derive the form of the grr with the help of the Karmarkar condition. In section 4, we present the new solution. Requirements for a physical solution are described in section 5. The interior solution is matched with the exterior Schwarzschild line element in section 6. Physical analysis of our solution and its compatibility with the observed pulsar are presented in sections 7 and 8. In section 10, the stability of the new model of the compact star is analysed. We conclude with a discussion of the results in section 11.
2. Einstein's equation
Assuming spherical symmetry for the relativistic superdense star, we consider the metric of the following form to describe the geometry inside it with coordinates (t, r, θ. φ).
Here the gravitational potentials, ν(r) and λ(r), are independent of the time coordinate.
We assume that the star is made up of anisotropic matter. The energy-momentum tensor consistent with the matter distribution inside the star is as follows:
Here ρ represents the energy density. pr and pt are the radial and tangential fluid pressures respectively. ui represents the 4-velocity of the fluid and ξi is a unit space-like 4-vector along the radial direction such that the following conditions are satisfied uiui = − 1, ξiξj = − 1 and uiξj = 0.
The Einstein field equations corresponding to spacetime metric (13) with G = c = 1 written as
where a prime (') denotes differentiation with respect to r. The anisotropic pressure which is the difference of pressures along transverse and radial directions is given by (using 4 and 5)
In general, a 4-dimensional space can be embedded in a 10-dimensional flat space. Eisenhart showed that a 4-dimensional spherically symmetric space is immersible in a 6-dimensional flat space. Therefore, it is embedded in class II space. Karmakar put forward a condition that is necessary and sufficient to embed a 4-dimensional spherically symmetric space in a 5-dimensional space, thereby making it of class I. In terms of the components of the Riemann curvature tensor, the condition can be expressed as follows:
It has been pointed out that the above equation (10) is the necessary and sufficient condition for the embedding of class-I when expressed in terms of the curvature components. It is interesting to note that the solution obtained by Pandey and Sharma [39] is not class-I type even though it satisfies the Karmarkar condition.
Integrating equation (10), we get a more simple form of the condition.
where F is an arbitrary constant. The Karmarkar condition furnishes a relation between the two metric potentials.
The generating function λ(r) thus provides us with a solution to the system as shown in the following section.
4. Generating a new solution
Das et al [38] have developed a new class of compact stellar models by choosing a particular metric potential grr and anisotropy thereby generating the gtt metric solution. Our aim is to develop a realistic model of the compact star. To achieve this end, we assume the metric potential gtt of the form
The assumed metric potential is finite, continuous, and well-defined inside the star. Now it may be noted that under certain assumptions this metric potential reduces to the well-known Tolman metric [40]. The assumed metric potential can be written as
Basically, relations (18) and (19) are the same. In those inequalities, R is the curvature parameter describing the geometry of the configuration having a dimension of length. The numerical value of R is in general much larger than the radii of pulsars which is evident from the value obtained from matching conditions [38]. Hence, the square of it i.e., R2 is considered much larger than 1 in equation (18) and equation (19). So, equation (17) can be expanded as
where $A=\tfrac{2}{\alpha }{\left(1-\beta \right)}^{2}$ and $B=\tfrac{{\left(1-\beta \right)}^{4}}{{\alpha }^{2}}$.
Here, A and B are constant parameters having dimensions L−2 and L−4 respectively. Equation (21) is the renowned Tolman metric that is widely used in the modeling of compact stars. The assumed metric potential, eν reduces to a well-known Tolman metric under certain conditions. In the expression of eν in equation (15) we can see that if we set
In equation (16), the metric takes a particular form. This particular relationship between the model parameters α, β, and R of equation (16) in this fashion helps one to reduce the assumed metric equation (13) to the Tolman metric. To have a Tolman-like metric one can restrict model parameters to obey equation (16). With the help of Karmarkar's condition (11) for generating embedded class I solution, we get the following solution for the metric potential, λ(r):
A feasible stellar solution of the Einstein field equations should obey the conditions listed as follows:
i
(i)The gravitational potentials and the matter variables should be well-defined at the center and singularity free throughout the star.
ii
(ii)Inside the star, the energy density ρ should be positive and its gradient should be negative, i.e., ρ ≥ 0 and $\tfrac{{\rm{d}}\rho }{{\rm{d}}{r}}\leqslant 0$.
iii
(iii)Inside the star, the radial pressure pr and the tangential pressure pt must be positive and their gradients should be negative, i.e., pr ≥ 0, pt ≥ 0, $\tfrac{{{\rm{d}}{p}}_{r}}{{\rm{d}}{r}}\lt 0$, $\tfrac{{{\rm{d}}{p}}_{t}}{{\rm{d}}{r}}\lt 0$.
iv
(iv)The radian pressure must be zero at the boundary of the star, i.e., at r = b. However, the tangential pressure pt may not vanish at r = b. The anisotropy must be zero at the center i.e., Δ(r = 0) = 0.
v
(v)Inside the anisotropic star, the Null Energy Condition and Strong Energy Condition of general relativity must be satisfied. This implies the following conditions: ρ + pr ≥ 0; ρ + pt ≥ 0; ρ + pr + 2pt ≥ 0.
vi
(vi)Inside the anisotropic star, the speed of sound must be subluminal, i.e., $0\leqslant \tfrac{{{\rm{d}}{p}}_{r}}{{\rm{d}}\rho }\leqslant 1$, $0\leqslant \tfrac{{{\rm{d}}{p}}_{t}}{{\rm{d}}\rho }\leqslant 1$. Here we have assumed the speed of light, c = 1.
vii
(vii) The metric potentials of the space-time inside the star should smoothly match the external space-time, i.e., the Schwarzschild space-time metric at r = b where b defines the radius of the star.
6. Matching with exterior space-time
We have considered a static spherically symmetric compact star. Hence the nature of the exterior spacetime may be described by the Schwarzschild line element
1. From equations (12) and (22), we note that at r = 0, ${{\rm{e}}}^{\nu (0)}={\left(\tfrac{\alpha }{{R}^{2}}+\beta \right)}^{2}=\mathrm{constant}$, eλ(0) = 1. Thus, the gravitational potentials are finite at the center of the star. We further note that, $({{\rm{e}}}^{\nu (r)}){{\prime} }_{r\,=\,0}=({{\rm{e}}}^{\lambda (r)}){{\prime} }_{r\,=\,0}=0$. Therefore, the metric potentials are well-behaved everywhere inside the star. Physical features of the metric potentials are shown graphically in figure 1.
As can be noted in figure 2, the above-mentioned physical quantities are all negative inside the star. The nature of the graphs proves that the density, as well as, the radial and tangential pressures are decreasing within the star.
As can be noted from figure 3, sound speeds in both directions lie in the interval [0, 1], where we assume the speed of light, c = 1. Therefore, the sound speeds are subluminal inside the star.
Figure 3. Variation of radial and transverse sound speeds against r.
5. The Null Energy Condition and Strong Energy Condition for the anisotropic star implies the conditions, ρ + pr ≥ 0, ρ + pt ≥ 0 and ρ + pr + 2pt ≥ 0, are satisfied everywhere inside the compact star. Figure 4 shows that the aforementioned energy conditions hold true throughout the star.
Figure 4. Fulfilment of energy conditions within the stellar interior.
6. Figure 1 shows that the metric potentials inside the star nicely match the exterior Schwarzschild metric functions at the boundary.
7. Equation of state of the constituent matter of the star, if assumed to be a perfect fluid, best described as P = P(ρ). In the present study, we have determined the geometry of the compact object. From the geometry, now, we can explore the nature of the matter content of the star. In figure 5, pressure is plotted as a function of the energy density. This indicates a nearly linear relationship between pressure and energy density. In figure 6, the red (solid) line indicates the pressure-energy density curve which best fits with the broken black straight line given as pr = 0.4621ρ − 211.
8. Mass-radius curve is also important for inferring the nature of the matter content of the star. Figure 7 shows the plot of the mass of the star in units of solar mass against the radius. The nature of the plot is consistent with the plots reported by previous studies.
9. Expression for the moment of inertia of compact astrophysical objects taking into consideration the effect of General Relativity is remarkably different from the expression for solid sphere given in mechanics. Using the slow rotation approximation proposed by Hartle [41], a number of attempts have been made for deriving an approximate expression for the moment of inertia of a compact star [42–44]. We use the approximate expression for the moment of inertia of the strange star provided in [45].
$\begin{eqnarray}{ \mathcal I }=0.4\left(1+\xi \right){{MR}}^{2}\end{eqnarray}$
Here, $\xi =\tfrac{M}{R}\tfrac{{km}}{{M}_{\odot }}$ is the dimensionless compactness parameter [46]. This value of the moment of inertia is valid up to the maximum mass of the star. In the next section, we plot ${ \mathcal I }$ against the mass of the star (see figure 8). The plot clearly shows a maximum value for the moment of inertia with the increasing mass of the star.
Figure 8. Variation of the moment of inertia of the star with mass.
8. Observational compatibility
The predicted values of mass and radius of the well-known pulsar 4U1820 − 30 are M = 1.58 M⊙ and R = 9.1 km, respectively [47]. Using these predicted values, one can immediately find out unknown constants α, β, F from equations (32)–(34) as follows: α = 1478.49, β = − 1.11081 and F=161.67 . Here, we assume R = 30. With the input of the calculated values of constants, we study the nature of different physical quantities in figures 9–12. In these plots, all physical quantities are expressed in usual C.G.S. units, substituting the values of G and c in proper places. The plots speak volumes about the physical viability of the model. Figure 9 shows that the density of the matter inside the star is maximum at the center and it gradually decreases towards the boundary. Radial and tangential pressures are also maximum at the center and the plots gradually decline toward the boundary of the star (see figure 10). Though the tangential pressure doesn't vanish at the boundary, the radial pressure becomes zero at the boundary of the star. The anisotropy is zero at r = 0 and maximum at the surface of the star.
The mass function is increasing throughout the star and vanishes at r = 0 (see figure 12). Pressure expressed as a thermodynamic function of the energy density represents the equation of state (EOS) of the constituent matter inside the star. Figure 5 studies the nature of the EOS. The plot represents an almost linear EOS.
The model developed in the present paper can be useful in describing pulsars of varied masses. In table 1, we use the estimated values of masses and radii of RX J 1856 − 37 [48], EXO 1785 − 248 [49], Her X-1 [50], PSR J 1614 − 2230, Cen X-3 and 4U 1608 − 52 to study the values of important model parameters.
Table 1. Values of model parameters.
Pulsar
Mass (M⊙)
Radius (km)
R
α
β
F
RX J 1856 − 37
0.9 ± 0.2
≈6
20
545.29
−0.7514
81.36
EXO 1785 − 248
1.3 ± 0.2
8.849 ± 0.4
34
2134.86
−1.2282
180.68
Her X-1
0.85 ± 0.15
8.1 ± 0.41
34
1687.83
−0.7169
211.94
PSR J 1614 − 2230
1.97 ± 0.04
9.69 ± 0.2
28
1202.03
−1.1091
156.56
Cen X-3
1.49 ± 0.08
9.178 ± 0.13
30
1310.32
−0.88439
175.88
4U1608 − 52
1.74 ± 0.14
9.52 ± 0.15
28
1053.33
−0.8403
168.08
The values of the physical quantities at physically significant points of the tar are given in table 2. These values are sufficient to justify the applicability of the model. Here, the notations ()∣0 and ()∣b are used to represent the calculated values of the physical parameters at the center and surface of the star, respectively.
Table 2. Values of physical quantities.
Pulsar
ρ∣0
ρ∣b
$\tfrac{{{dp}}_{r}}{d\rho }{| }_{0}$
$\tfrac{{{dp}}_{r}}{d\rho }{| }_{b}$
$\tfrac{{{dp}}_{t}}{d\rho }{| }_{0}$
$\tfrac{{{dp}}_{t}}{d\rho }{| }_{b}$
(ρ + pr + 2pt)∣0
(ρ + pr + 2pt)∣b
RX J 1856 − 37
1390
950
0.70
0.38
0.65
0.25
2012
1023
EXO 1785 − 248
674
411
0.38
0.29
0.32
0.18
931
462
Her X-1
496
382
0.48
0.33
0.41
0.21
614
416
PSR J 1614 − 2230
872
432
0.79
0.42
0.78
0.28
1670
508
Cen X-3
660
425
0.64
0.36
0.58
0.23
1035
469
4U 1608 − 52
716
425
0.87
0.41
0.84
0.27
1248
482
9. Equilibrium under three different forces
The static equilibrium of an anisotropic star under the gravitational, hydro-static, and anisotropic forces may be described by the following equation:
where MG(r) is the gravitational mass of the star within the radius r. Its value can be computed using the Tolman-Whittaker formula and the Einsteins field equations as follows:
which represent the gravitational, hydrostatics and anisotropic forces, respectively.
The plot of the aforementioned forces is given in figure 13. The figure shows that the negativity of gravitational force is balanced by positive forces, like, hydro-static and anisotropic force and thereby maintaining the static equilibrium of the system.
This quantity is closely connected to an anisotropic star's stability. Researchers [51] have reported the value of the adiabatic index to remain in the range ${\rm{\Gamma }}\gt \tfrac{4}{3}$ for the stable equilibrium of an isotropic sphere. Figure 14 shows the plot of Γr. It can be noted that Γr satisfies the requirement for stability everywhere inside the star.
Figure 15. ${v}_{t}^{2}-{v}_{r}^{2}$ is plotted against r.
10.2. Causality condition
In a realistic model of an anisotropic star, the sound speeds inside the star must be subluminal, i.e., $0\leqslant \tfrac{{{\rm{d}}{p}}_{r}}{{\rm{d}}\rho }\leqslant 1$, $0\leqslant \tfrac{{{\rm{d}}{p}}_{t}}{{\rm{d}}\rho }\leqslant 1$. This is termed the causality condition. Utilizing the ‘cracking' concept proposed by Herrera [52], Abreau et. al [53] showed that the probable condition for a model of a compact star to be stable is $-1\leqslant {v}_{{st}}^{2}-{v}_{{sr}}^{2}\leqslant 0$. Andréasson [54] modified this range as $0\lt | {v}_{{st}}^{2}-{v}_{{sr}}^{2}| \lt 1$. Figure 15 shows that the sound speeds are less than one inside the star. Therefore, the causality condition is satisfied throughout the star.
11. Discussions
In this paper, we have obtained an embedding class -I type interior solution to the Einstein field equations for an anisotropic matter distribution. This has been achieved by employing the Karmakar condition. The solutions we obtained are regular and well-behaved and could be used to describe a relativistic compact anisotropic star. All the physically relevant parameters e.g., metric potentials, density, pressures, mass, and anisotropy are positive and singularity free in every part of the star. The gradients of the matter variables are negative throughout the structure indicating that they pick a maximum value at the centre and gradually decrease towards the boundary of the star. One interesting feature of our approach is that we have not assumed any equation of state relating to the pressure and density of the matter composition of the star. Our approach enables us to find a relationship between these thermodynamical parameters. The relationship between the energy density and radial pressure which reflects the nature of the equation of state (EoS) of the matter distribution shows an almost linear relationship. The Karmakar condition allowed us to determine both the metric potentials and the nature of the EoS that can be predicted from the plot.
The nature of the mass-radius curve obtained in the present study agrees very well with the plots reported in the literature. The plot of the moment of inertia against the mass of the star shows a maximum value for the moment of inertia with the increasing mass of the star.
A stable configuration demands that it should satisfy the TolmanOppenheimerVolkoff equilibrium condition. The stability of the model has been demonstrated graphically where the gravitational force is counterbalanced by the combined effect of the anisotropic and hydro-static force. A few other parameters that should be verified for stable conditions are also checked here. We verify the sound speeds in both radial and transverse directions obey the corresponding limit. Further, Herrera's cracking condition has been verified in our proposed model.
It was first described by Chandrasekhar [55] that any stellar configuration will maintain its stability if the adiabatic index Γ > 4/3. This has been clearly shown graphically.
One interesting feature of the assumed metric of our model is that under a particular approximation, it is reduced to the well-known Tolman metric.
FR and SD would like to thank the authorities of the Inter-University Centre for Astronomy and Astrophysics, Pune, India for providing research facilities.
DasSRaySKhlopovMNandiK KParidaB K2021 Anisotropic Compact Stars: Constraining model parameter to account for physical features of tidal love numbers Anns. of Phys.433 168597
DebDGhoshSMauryaS KKhlopovMRayS Anisotropic compact stars in f(T) gravity under Karmakar condition arXiv:1811.11797
37
PantNGedelaSRaySSagarK G2022 Relativistic charged stellar model of the Pant interior solution via gravitational decoupling and Karmakar conditions Mod. Phys. Lett. A37 2250072
GangopadhyayTRaySLiX-DDeyJDeyM2013 Strange star equation of state fits the refined mass measurement of 12 pulsars and predicts their radii Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc.431 3216
PonsJ AWalterF MLattimerJ MPrakashMNeuhauserRAnP2002 Towards a mass and radius determination of the nearby isolated neutron star RX J185635-3754 Astrophys. J.564 981